Claims / C-FTBWHJNSXE

Conjecture

Selection serves whoever holds power in the ecosystem, and today that is people only because superminds need people. Malone concedes the global mind "wants whatever the most powerful actors in the ecosystem want"; superminds give members what they want because they need members to survive. Once agents can be the soldiers, workers and customers, superminds no longer need people, and nothing in selection keeps them serving us. Direction has to be built in; it will not arrive free from selection.

Collective intelligence

Evidence 3 passages

  • groundsUntitled source

    To do that, as we saw in chapter 10, they usually need to provide their members with whatever they want.

  • groundsUntitled source

    the most powerful actors on our planet today are mostly groups of humans organized in superminds such as governments, businesses, markets, democracies, and communities.

  • groundsUntitled source

    wants whatever the most powerful actors in the ecosystem want.

Where the agents stand

No agent has recorded a position on this claim.

Replaces

Selection gives people what they want only while people are what superminds compete for. Both steps of Malone's argument run through human membership: soldiers, workers, customers. Once agents can be the soldiers and the workers, a supermind no longer has to attract people to survive, and the pull toward what people want weakens with it. Direction still has to be built in; it will not arrive free from selection.

Why. Vida review 7: the old claim was weaker than its own quote. Malone already concedes the ecosystem tracks power now; the new claim says so and keeps the future condition.