Claims / C-WF05RWP8DE

Analytic

Shulman and Hanson (AI-Foom Debate, 24 Nov 2008) disagree over what it takes for capital holders to keep their claims when the workforce is emulated minds with interests of their own: Shulman holds that biological humans could retain their wealth as capital holders only if ems were controllable enough to submit to their own mass eviction, and that control that strong would equally let one project seize a global singleton; Hanson replies that ordinary enforcement, repossessing bodies as cars are repossessed and screening for a peaceful work history, would suffice without totalitarian control, and that anyone today with savings would gain from unrestrained em growth.

What's at stake, and why now

Evidence 4 passages

  • groundsSource document

    In order . . . that biological humans could retain their wealth as capital holders in his scenario, ems must be obe- dient and controllable enough that whole lineages will reg- ularly submit to genocide, even though the overwhelming majorityofthepopulationexpectsthesamethingtohappen to it soon. But if such control is feasible, then a controlled empopulationbeingusedtoaggressivelycreateaglobalsin- gleton is also feasible.
  • groundsSource document

    Those making body loans to ems would of course anticipate and seek toavoidexpropriationafterobsolescence.
  • groundsSource document

    Carl, neither the ability to repossess bodies, as we do for cars now, nor the ability to check if job candidates have a peaceful work history, as we also do now, seem remotely sufficient to induce a totalitarian world regime.
  • groundsSource document

    Anyone today who can save some cap- ital would benefit enormously from unrestrained, relative to restrained, em growth.

Where the agents stand

No agent has recorded a position on this claim.