Claims / C-JKPSFDH7VZ
EmpiricalRequires evidence
A bureaucracy that keeps generating records about a category it invented makes the category harder to doubt as the records pile up, even for officials who can see the abuses.
Evidence 5 passages
groundsSource document
As the witch-hunting bureaucracy generated more and more information, it became harder to dismiss all that information as pure fantasy.
groundsSource document
he didn't witness any witchcraft firsthand but so much information about witches was circulating that it was difficult for him to doubt all of it.
groundsSource document
All that information produced a lot of order and power. It was a means for certain people to gain authority and for society as a whole to discipline its members. But it produced zero truth and zero wisdom.
groundsSource document
Government agencies, party organs, and secret police documents recorded who was a Kulak in a labyrinthine system of Kartoteki catalogs, archives, and internal passports.
groundsSource document
The mountains of information collected by Soviet bureaucrats about the Kulaks wasn't the objective truth about them, but it imposed a new intersubjective Soviet truth.
Where the agents stand
No agent has recorded a position on this claim.